WinstonWınston
Back
Nicolet Bankshares logo

Nicolet Bankshares

NIC
62
Banks - Regional · Financial Services
Price
$173.23
+1.54 (+0.90%)
Market Cap
$2.99B
Exchange
New York Stock Exchange
Winston Score
62
Winston is curious
A decent business — some strong pillars, some weaker.
Data as of Aug 23, 2026 · filings through Jun 30, 2026
How the score breaks down
Growth
Good
Valuation
Strong
Dividends
Good

Share count rising — dilution

+38.2% over 4y

The company has issued more shares over this period, which dilutes each existing shareholder’s stake.

Diluted shares outstanding: 11.1M (2021) → 15.4M (2025)

Winston Score History

The full picture

Nicolet Bankshares is a regional bank holding company based in Green Bay, Wisconsin. It offers everyday banking services like checking and savings accounts, loans, mortgages, and wealth management to individuals and businesses across Wisconsin, Michigan, and Minnesota. The company has grown largely through acquisitions, buying smaller community banks over the years to expand its footprint across the upper Midwest.

Nicolet makes money the traditional banking way — it takes in deposits and lends that money out at higher interest rates, earning the difference, called net interest income. It also collects fees from wealth management and other financial services. With roughly $8 billion in total assets, it is a mid-sized community bank competing against both large national banks and smaller local ones. Its main competitive edge is deep local relationships and a community-focused approach that larger banks often cannot match. The biggest risk the company faces is rising credit losses if the economy slows and borrowers struggle to repay loans.

Score breakdown

Every number that matters to educated investors.

Each metric is explained in plain language so you know exactly what you're looking at. Start your free trial now.

Bank Quality

Not applicable for this business.

Growth

Sales growth
Sales YoY
-2.7%
Shrinking sales (-2.7% YoY)
Profit growth
EPS YoY
+3.1%
Modest earnings growth (+3.1% YoY)

Single-digit earnings growth — steady but not exciting.

How steady the profit is
EPS Consistency
7/8 quarters
Every recent quarter grew earnings vs last year

Full breakdown available with your free trial

See every metric, trend, and what it means for this stock.

Try free

Capital Strength

Not applicable for this business.

Asset Quality

Not applicable for this business.

Valuation

Price vs profit
P/E Ratio (TTM)
18.8x
Fair value — P/E 18.8

P/E in the normal range. Price is roughly $15 for every $1 of yearly profit.

Cheaper or dearer next year
P/E vs Forward
+3.6
GROWING
Earnings expected to grow meaningfully — cheaper on forward P/E (18.8 → 15.1)

Full breakdown available with your free trial

See every metric, trend, and what it means for this stock.

Try free

Dividends

Dividend
Dividend Yield
0.74%
Small dividend — 0.74% yield

Modest yield. The bulk of any return needs to come from price appreciation.

Dividend record
Dividend Growth
+13.3%
Dividend growing fast (13.3% YoY)

Full breakdown available with your free trial

See every metric, trend, and what it means for this stock.

Try free
🔒 See full fundamentals and if they are improving or declining — click here for your free trial now.
Start free trial